CPJ Market

2 Ratings
Pepper Jelly Grilled Cheese



  1. To assemble, place cheese slices evenly spread out on one side of the sandwich bread
  2. Spread pepper jelly evenly on the inside of the other piece of bread and place on top of bottom slice
  3. Put half of the butter in a small skillet on medium heat
  4. Once melted, place the sandwich in the pan and wait until golden brown on underside (approx. 1 minute)
  5. Lift up the sandwich with a spatula and put remaining amount of butter in the pan
  6. Once evenly spread out, place sandwich back in skillet and cook on other side until golden brown
  7. Slice and serve!